
When there are times that we are tempted to throw our hands up in the air and say “what is the point?”, let us remember that despair gets us nowhere and sows the seeds of apathy.
Incrementalism is not enough to address the fierce urgency of now, but neither is the self-defeating fatalism that comes from the belief that all hope is lost. Better is more good than worse, and less worse is better than more worse. Giving up is not a moral option. Every action for good that we take matters.
We often see hopelessness and fatalism expressed by a number of people when it comes to our political situation. If you are feeling hopeless about politics, thinking that nothing can be done, and that your vote doesn’t really matter; the people and powers that benefit from the status quo have you right where they want you. Given that only 45% of registered voters in Oklahoma actually voted in the midterms, the oligarchs seem to have a lot of Oklahomans right where they want them.
The decision not to participate in the political process gives narcissistic and nihilistic billionaires free rein to continue controlling our politics and economics and to continue profiting off the annihilation of nature and human civilization.
So much of our life is about making choices among less than ideal options, and sometimes all the options we have to choose from are all not good; but more often than not, the decision not to choose at all is actually the worst choice we can make.
If the goal of ethics is to maximize value and minimize suffering for all life over the long-run, this requires us to sometimes make choices for the less worse over the more worse. Such necessary choices rarely draw attention or bring those make them societal praise of even recognition, but they are part of the daily hard work of bringing a better world into existence.
Making the better choice among less than ideal options requires that we think carefully and critically about the values that matter most for the flourishing of all life and about the obligations we have in relation to humanity and the Earth. This is not easy work. It is complex and nuanced, but it is vital work for the continued existence and sustainable flourishing of humanity.
One of the reasons I am drawn to Unitarian Universalism is because it has taken on this difficult and necessary work of clarifying what its shared values are and making sure that these values are such that they cultivate and contribute to a Beloved Community for all life on earth. These shared values can help us make the better and best choices when none of the options we have to choose from is ideal.
As we recall the UU shared values of pluralism, generosity, interdependence, equity, justice, and transformation all held together with love at the center, let us all take note that non-participation is not on our list of shared values. Not making difficult choices is not on our list of shared values. And giving up is not on our list of shared values. We are a community with love at the center, and love is always engaged and participates for a more just and beloved community, Love always finds a way to make the choices to bring more value rather than less value into the world, and love never gives up. Love never gives up and nether shall we. Neither shall we.